Appetizer Main course Recipes Vegetarian

Cheddar and Potato Soup

January 25, 2013

As frigid temperatures and bitter cold winds have taken over the Northeast these past few days, I can hardly think of a better time to whip up a big pot of cheesy soup to warm me from the inside out. I could honestly eat any kind of soup every day during wintertime but right now calls for some serious decadence and this Cheddar and Potato soup really fits the bill.

You only need a few simple ingredients to make this sumptuous soup so don’t skimp on them, i.e. get a really good cheddar and buy fresh sage as they are both crucial to the dish’s flavor.  The result is a thick and creamy potato base in which you scatter to your liking chunks of cheddar cheese, a unique and playful way to enjoy this popular duo. You can be as liberal or stingy as you wish with the cheese (I’m definitely of the former camp!) which gives you control over the richness of the soup, though any way you decide to go it’ll still end up being the rich and super comforting solution to your winter blues. Now all you have to do is fill a big bowl, grab a piece of thick bread, and go hide under the covers until the storm passes…

Cheddar and Potato Soup

Recipe from the restaurant Alias in New York
Active time: 20 minutes
Total time: 35 minutes
Makes 4 servings
2 cups milk
1 qt heavy cream
8 Yukon gold potatoes, peeled and quartered
½ tablespoon kosher salt
½ lb aged cheddar cheese
10 fresh sage leaves
Fresh cracked black pepper

Pour milk and cream into a saucepan. Add potatoes and kosher salt and bring to a steady simmer (never boil the potatoes).

When the potatoes are fork tender, strain and save liquid.

Mash potatoes and add milk and cream back (use potato masher or blender). The texture should coat the back of a spoon.

Chunk up cheese with a fork so they are about ½-inch chunks and cut sage into strips.


Pour soup into 4 warm shallow soup bowls until about ¼ inch below rim. Add cheese around the bowl liberally (you should see the chunks). Sprinkle each bowl with sage and grind fresh black pepper over the entire soup.

Print This Post Print This Post


You Might Also Like

  • Lokness @ The Missing Lokness January 25, 2013 at 6:19 pm

    Creamy and cheesy soup…. Yum! Sounds just about right for today’s cool and rainy weather.

  • Mrs. Measurement January 26, 2013 at 10:12 am

    Mmmmmm! Looks amaze and super simple to make. Thanks for sharing.